Michelangelo's Pizza in Holly Springs, NC, is not just another pizza place; it's a cherished community spot where delicious food meets a warm atmosphere. Reviewers consistently praise the friendly staff and exceptional buffet options. One guest, Sebastian Enevoldsen, perfectly encapsulated the vibe by highlighting the staff's kindness alongside the mouthwatering pizza.
The buffet, a standout feature, has garnered rave reviews. Christopher Caudle enjoyed the variety that included not only pizza but also fresh salads, pasta, and even chicken wings on weekends. This diversity ensures there's something for everyone, making it an ideal dining destination for both families and groups.
Marie Schelkle, a fan of the Wednesday senior buffet, appreciates the ample choices, from garlic knots to savory soups. E Kinlaw emphasizes the customization possibilities, noting that the staff is eager to accommodate special pizza requests. For larger gatherings, Jenny McClamroch recommends their monster pizzas, which offer great value and generous portions—enough to feed an entire party with leftovers!
In summary, Michelangelo's Pizza is a delightful blend of quality food and a welcoming environment, perfect for casual dining or special occasions.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Offers delivery
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Has all you can eat
Serves comfort food
Quick bite
Dining options
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Has catering
Serves dessert
Has seating
Amenities
Has toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Crowd
Good for groups
Planning
Doesn't accept reservations
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs available
Has kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Photos
Reviews For Michelangelo's Pizza
Sebastian Enevoldsen
Jul 13,2025
What a bunch of nice people working here! And great pizza, too! :)
Christopher Caudle
Jul 11,2025
Had the buffet and when I ordered they asked me what kind of pizzas I wanted added to it which was awesome. Salad bar was fresh! In addition to pizza, they had an assortment of pastas. They also had chicken wings on the bar which I was told only happens on Saturdays and Sundays. Overall great experience and I will be back.
Marie Schelkle
May 25,2025
Love the senior buffet on Wednesday evenings. Delicious pizza, lots of variety. Garlic knots, several pasta choices and soups. Great salad bar!
E Kinlaw
May 22,2025
Some of the best buffet pizza around. Staff are super friendly and ready to make any pizza you desire.
Jenny McClamroch
May 12,2025
Ordered a few monster pizzas for a party! Huge, delicious and such a great price! We fed 13 adults and 20 kids on two monsters with leftovers! The entire third pizza is in my freezer The staff was friendly and delivered!
Katie Taylor
Apr 25,2025
After trying several pizza buffets in this area, Michelangelo’s is far and away the best. It’s hot, fresh, full of variety, and clean! I only wish this place was closer to me in Garner ...
Amy Lynn
Apr 23,2025
The best pizza experience in years. The restaurant was clean and had a friendly family atmosphere. I did the lunch buffet and it was incredible. Fresh delicious veggies on a fully stocked salad bar. They offered soup as well. The pizza was "Awesome" !!!! Hot fresh pizza Bar. They take request for your favorite pizza and it's out in 10 min. They are generous on their toppings unlike all the other pizza places in the area. My daughter and I enjoyed every minute and every bite. If you want a perfect pizza go to Michelangelo's. Try their buffalo chicken it is my personal favorite! Enjoy
Sidney Martich
Apr 10,2025
I’ve ordered from this place regularly for the past almost a year. When I moved down here from New York, I gave up on finding “New York pizza”. This place is fantastic and would have had amazing reviews even smack in the middle of Manhattan. Thank you so much for giving me a taste of home!
Reviews For Michelangelo's Pizza